Addy v FCT [2021] HCA 34
A UK national on a working holiday visa was taxed at a higher rate than an Australian national would be. She said this was unlawful under a treaty because it subjected her to ‘other or more burdensome’ taxation than Australians ‘in the same circumstances …in particular with respect to residence’10.
The court …
Patten v Mareangareu [2021] VSCA 295
A police officer was convicted of offences and dismissed. The convictions were later quashed and he sought reappointment13. The trial judge said the power to reappoint ‘should be construed beneficially for the police officer’ and ordered reappointment.
The appeal court, however, held (at [57]) that to identify a beneficial purpose up-front ‘may …
Statutory interpretation was once seen as a ‘non-subject’1 and judges told people not to read books on it2. We now live in ‘the age of statutes’, however, and things could not be more different. Working out what statutes mean is the singular most important legal skill to have in the 21st century. Textbooks are crucial to …
Every statute is a ‘diktat by the state to the citizen’1. Interpretation of these diktats really matters. A recent case where a mining company sued the State on constitutional grounds illustrates this2. The main issue was whether amendments validly took away the benefit of earlier arbitral awards3. Part of the argument was whether State …
DPP Reference No 1 of 2019 [2021] HCA 26
A 1995 case set the test for criminal recklessness in Victoria as awareness of the accused that serious injury would probably result4. Later amendments were silent on the test to be applied. The test in NSW required only a possibility in this regard, and the High Court later also …
Sydney Seaplanes v Page [2021] NSWCA 204
A woman died in a plane crash in 2017. Less than 2 years later (just within the limitation period), her father sued the operator for damages in the FCA. This was dismissed, as the flight was wholly within NSW. To re-start in the NSWSC, there had to be ‘an order of a federal …
Genesian Theatre v NSW [2021] NSWSC 1089
Paula Bate said many times she wanted to leave everything to the theatre. There was no dispute about this, but she never made a will. She died, her estate vested in the State, and the theatre tried to claim it – refused. The issue was whether the theatre as a corporation was a …
AAI Limited v Technology Swiss [2021] FCAFC 168
This insurance case (at [163]) stresses that the meaning of a contract has nothing to do with subjective intentions of the parties. The High Court case quoted from, Byrnes v Kendall, makes parallel observations for statutes13. From every angle, interpretation in both spheres is to be objective.
With statutes, …
Rarely comes a case that is truly iconoclastic, but Thaler v Commissioner of Patents is one of them1. It smashes the cherished norm that an ‘inventor’ must be a natural person. In a world first, Beach J held that an AI system (known as DABUS) can be an ‘inventor’ for patent law purposes2 – here, of a …
Thaler v Commissioner of Patents [2021] FCA 879
On the use of dictionaries to resolve the meaning of ‘inventor’, Beach J in Thaler (at [15]) said more was required than ‘mere resort to old millennium usages’. If words are only ‘pictures of ideas’, the judge needed ‘to grapple with the underlying idea’.
The judge (at [147-153) noted – (1) choice …
